Tell me about a time when you had to handle a difficult employee


 Theme: Employee Management, Conflict Resolution  Role: Assistant Manager  Function: Retail

  Interview Question for Assistant Manager:  See sample answers, motivations & red flags for this common interview question. About Assistant Manager: Supports the store manager in various tasks, such as staff supervision, scheduling, and customer service. This role falls within the Retail function of a firm. See other interview questions & further information for this role here

 Sample Answer 


  Example response for question delving into Employee Management, Conflict Resolution with the key points that need to be covered in an effective response. Customize this to your own experience with concrete examples and evidence

  •  Identifying the difficult employee: I had a situation where one of my team members consistently arrived late to work and had a negative attitude towards customers and colleagues. I noticed this behavior through regular observation and feedback from other team members
  •  Addressing the issue directly: I scheduled a private meeting with the employee to discuss their behavior. I approached the conversation with empathy and expressed my concerns about their lateness and attitude. I provided specific examples of incidents and explained how it was impacting the team and the overall store environment
  •  Active listening & understanding: During the meeting, I actively listened to the employee's perspective and allowed them to express their concerns or frustrations. I acknowledged their feelings and validated their experiences, while also emphasizing the importance of professionalism and teamwork
  •  Setting clear expectations: I clearly communicated the expectations for punctuality, customer service, and teamwork. I explained the consequences of not meeting these expectations, including potential disciplinary actions. I also offered support and resources to help the employee improve their performance
  •  Developing an action plan: Together with the employee, I developed an action plan to address their lateness and attitude. We identified specific steps they would take to improve, such as setting alarms, attending a customer service training, and seeking guidance from more experienced team members
  •  Monitoring & providing feedback: I closely monitored the employee's progress and provided regular feedback. I recognized and praised their improvements, while also addressing any setbacks or recurring issues. I ensured open communication channels for them to seek guidance or discuss any challenges they faced
  •  Documenting the process: Throughout the entire process, I maintained detailed records of our conversations, the agreed action plan, and any performance-related incidents. This documentation helped in tracking progress, providing evidence for future discussions, and ensuring consistency in handling the situation
  •  Resolving the issue: Over time, the employee's lateness improved, and their attitude towards customers and colleagues became more positive. They became a valued member of the team, and the overall store environment improved as a result of addressing the issue
  •  Learning & growth: This experience taught me the importance of addressing issues promptly, maintaining open communication, and providing support to employees. It also reinforced the significance of documentation and consistency in handling difficult employee situations

 Underlying Motivations 


  What the Interviewer is trying to find out about you and your experiences through this question

  •  Leadership skills: Assessing your ability to handle challenging situations and difficult employees
  •  Conflict resolution: Evaluating your approach to resolving conflicts and maintaining a positive work environment
  •  Communication skills: Understanding how effectively you communicate with employees and address their concerns
  •  Problem-solving abilities: Determining your problem-solving skills in dealing with difficult employees

 Potential Minefields 


  How to avoid some common minefields when answering this question in order to not raise any red flags

  •  Blaming the employee: Avoid blaming the difficult employee for the situation or their behavior. Instead, focus on how you effectively managed the situation
  •  Lack of empathy: Avoid showing a lack of empathy towards the difficult employee. Instead, emphasize your ability to understand their perspective and find a solution that benefits both parties
  •  Inability to communicate: Avoid mentioning any difficulties in communication with the employee without providing a resolution. Instead, highlight your strong communication skills and how you effectively addressed the issue
  •  Lack of problem-solving skills: Avoid demonstrating a lack of problem-solving skills when dealing with the difficult employee. Instead, showcase your ability to analyze the situation, identify the root cause, and implement a solution
  •  Inflexibility: Avoid showing inflexibility in your approach to handling the difficult employee. Instead, emphasize your adaptability and willingness to find alternative solutions
  •  Ineffective conflict resolution: Avoid mentioning any instances where conflicts escalated or were not resolved satisfactorily. Instead, focus on your ability to mediate conflicts and reach mutually beneficial resolutions