Tell me about a time when you had to deal with a difficult hiring manager. How did you handle it?


 Theme: Stakeholder Management  Role: Recruiter  Function: Human Resources

  Interview Question for Recruiter:  See sample answers, motivations & red flags for this common interview question. About Recruiter: Finds and hires suitable candidates for job openings. This role falls within the Human Resources function of a firm. See other interview questions & further information for this role here

 Sample Answer 


  Example response for question delving into Stakeholder Management with the key points that need to be covered in an effective response. Customize this to your own experience with concrete examples and evidence

  •  Difficult Hiring Manager: Provide a brief overview of the situation and the specific challenges posed by the difficult hiring manager
  •  Communication & Relationship Building: Explain how you established open and effective communication with the hiring manager, building a positive relationship
  •  Understanding Needs & Expectations: Describe how you actively listened and probed to understand the hiring manager's needs and expectations
  •  Managing Expectations: Discuss how you set realistic expectations with the hiring manager regarding the recruitment process and timelines
  •  Collaboration & Problem-Solving: Highlight how you collaborated with the hiring manager to address any issues or concerns, finding mutually beneficial solutions
  •  Providing Expertise & Guidance: Explain how you leveraged your HR expertise to provide guidance and advice to the hiring manager, ensuring compliance and best practices
  •  Maintaining Professionalism: Discuss how you remained calm, composed, and professional throughout the interactions with the difficult hiring manager
  •  Successful Outcome: Summarize the positive outcome achieved through your efforts, such as successfully filling the position or improving the hiring manager's satisfaction

 Underlying Motivations 


  What the Interviewer is trying to find out about you and your experiences through this question

  •  Conflict resolution skills: Assessing how well you handle difficult situations and interpersonal conflicts
  •  Communication skills: Evaluating your ability to effectively communicate and manage expectations
  •  Problem-solving abilities: Understanding your approach to resolving challenges and finding solutions
  •  Relationship-building skills: Assessing your ability to establish and maintain positive working relationships
  •  Adaptability: Determining how well you can navigate and adjust to challenging situations

 Potential Minefields 


  How to avoid some common minefields when answering this question in order to not raise any red flags

  •  Blaming the hiring manager: Avoid blaming or badmouthing the hiring manager as it shows a lack of professionalism and ability to handle conflicts
  •  Lack of problem-solving skills: Avoid not providing a clear solution or strategy to handle the difficult hiring manager
  •  Inability to adapt: Avoid not demonstrating flexibility or adaptability in dealing with different personalities and situations
  •  Lack of communication skills: Avoid not emphasizing effective communication and collaboration with the hiring manager to resolve conflicts
  •  Negative attitude: Avoid displaying a negative or confrontational attitude towards the hiring manager